Новые утечки документов показывают, что в начале 2024 года израильские военные перенесли около 3,5 миллиона фотографий палестинцев в облачную систему Amazon. Цель заключалась в том, чтобы проанализировать их с помощью системы распознавания лиц компании ...
Сообщение Planet-Today.com. Перевод заголовка и краткого описания выполнен автоматически.
New leaked files show the Israeli military moved roughly 3.5 million photographs of Palestinians into Amazon’s cloud system in early 2024. The goal was to run them through the company’s facial recognition tool while fighting was still intense in Gaza. Mainstream reports focus on the technical details. Other outlets ask harder questions about how far the tracking can reach and what it means when a private American company holds the data. The full picture sits between those views.
What the Leaked Documents Actually Say
On 16 November 2026, The Guardian published an investigation by Harry Davies and Yuval Abraham based on leaked documents and talks with military sources. It states that a unit inside the Israeli Defense Forces, known as Rolling Stone, uploaded the 3.5 million images to an Amazon Web Services data center near Tel Aviv. The unit told Amazon in early 2024 that it planned to use Rekognition, Amazon’s AI image analysis service, for a facial recognition project.
Rolling Stone manages a large database of information on Palestinians living in Gaza and the West Bank. That collection includes identity-card photos, family details, property records, checkpoint crossings, and work permits. Sources familiar with the work say soldiers have long used these photos with facial recognition tools, including a phone app called Blue Wolf used in the West Bank.
After Israeli forces entered Gaza in late October 2023, they set up temporary checkpoints. Cameras took pictures of people passing through, often after they had been forced to move by bombing. The pictures were matched against existing military records. A military source told the Guardian that Amazon’s cloud was used because of the “very large scale” of images collected at those sites. The investigation notes it is not clear whether all 3.5 million photos came from the Gaza checkpoints or from older archives as well. It is also not clear whether the work on Amazon’s system became fully operational.
The Jerusalem Post reported the same Guardian findings the same day, framing them as claims based on the leaked material. The paper added that Israel’s AI chief later warned about the risks of relying on foreign companies for critical systems and the need for more local data centers.
Project Nimbus and the Wider Cloud Shift
The photo upload fits a larger pattern. In 2021 Israel signed Project Nimbus, a multi-billion-dollar contract with Amazon and Google to move government and military data into their cloud services. Documents show the Israeli military received access to a specially protected section inside Amazon’s Tel Aviv data center, sometimes called a “walled garden,” for sensitive material related to operations and intelligence.
Throughout 2023, Rolling Stone moved large volumes of its data into that protected area. One source involved in the move said the plan was to shift “photographs, video, all the secret intelligence information—everything” from military servers to Amazon’s cloud. Earlier Guardian reporting on the Nimbus deal described terms that limit Amazon’s and Google’s ability to restrict or suspend Israeli use even if terms of service are broken, and a system for coded notice if foreign authorities seek the data.
Amazon has said it has no visibility into what customers run in its cloud and does not discuss customer relationships without consent. It described visits by Israeli personnel to its Tel Aviv offices as routine briefings. The IDF has declined to comment on specific contracts or operational methods.
Earlier Uses of the Same Technology
Facial recognition was already in use before the large upload. In the first days after the 7 October 2023 Hamas attack, Israeli forces and volunteers used Amazon’s Rekognition and other tools to scan images and videos posted online and compare them with photos supplied by families. The aim was to identify missing people, hostages, and victims. Later, the same methods were applied to flag people the military suspected of militant activity.
The New York Times previously reported that the military experimented with commercial facial recognition systems in Gaza, including tools from an Israeli company called Corsight and Google Photos. Those tests sometimes wrongly labeled civilians as militants. The technology can pull faces from crowds or low-quality drone footage, but accuracy drops in real conditions.
Older independent tests of Amazon Rekognition itself raised accuracy questions. Research from the MIT Media Lab in 2019 found higher error rates when the system tried to classify the gender of darker-skinned women compared with lighter-skinned men. The American Civil Liberties Union tested the tool against photos of U.S. members of Congress and reported dozens of false matches to mugshots, with higher rates for people of color. Amazon disputed the methods and said later internal tests showed improved results. Those earlier studies remain part of the public record on the tool’s performance.
What Different Outlets Emphasize
Mainstream coverage, led by The Guardian and carried by outlets such as the Jerusalem Post and Yahoo News, sticks closely to the leaked documents and named sources. It describes the upload, the role of the Rolling Stone unit, the connection to Project Nimbus, and the open questions about exactly which images were included and whether the system was fully used in operations. It notes long-standing Israeli practices of facial scanning at West Bank checkpoints and the security rationale after the October 7 attack.
Alternative reports, including one from The People’s Voice, use the same core numbers but add stronger claims. They state that the system is meant to track and kill enemies “anywhere in the world.” The Guardian investigation does not contain that specific language. The documents and sources describe databases focused on Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank and use at local checkpoints. Broader claims about global reach are not supported by the published material from the primary investigation.
Critics of large biometric systems argue that once photos and personal data sit in a commercial cloud, the risk of misuse or error grows. Supporters of the Israeli approach point to the need to identify people who took part in the October 7 attack and to prevent further attacks while forces operate in a dense urban area. Both sides can point to real events: hostages were identified with the help of facial tools, and some civilians were wrongly flagged in earlier tests.
Practical Limits and Open Questions
Several facts remain unclear even after the Guardian report. It is not known how many of the 3.5 million images were new photos taken at Gaza checkpoints versus older identity-card pictures already in the Rolling Stone system. It is not known whether the facial recognition work done on Amazon’s platform produced operational results or stayed in a testing phase. Amazon states it cannot see the content of customer workloads. The IDF does not discuss operational tools.
Facial recognition systems still struggle with poor lighting, partial views, and large crowds. When the cost of a false match is high—detention, further investigation, or targeting—those technical limits matter. The same systems can also correctly match a known face quickly when the photo quality is good and the database is limited. Both outcomes have been documented in previous reporting on the Gaza campaign.
The transfer also raises ordinary questions about data location and control. Sensitive personal information about people living under military administration now sits, at least in part, on servers owned by a U.S. company inside Israel. Project Nimbus was designed to keep much of that data inside Israeli borders while still using commercial infrastructure. Whether that arrangement fully protects the data from later legal demands or internal access is a matter of the contract terms, which have been reported but not fully published.
Related Patterns in Surveillance Technology
The Amazon upload is one piece of a wider picture. Israeli companies and units have developed and sold surveillance tools for years. Recent reporting on this site has covered cases in which Israeli-linked spyware advertising systems reached European government networks, and deals in which U.S. police bought Israeli-made cell-site equipment. Those stories sit alongside the facial recognition work: commercial technology, military or security customers, and questions about how far the data travels and who controls it.
See also: Israeli Spyware Ads Reached Italy’s Central Bank and Defense Networks and FalcoNet Spy Vans: What Texas Police Bought and Why It Matters.
Where the Evidence Stands
The core claim rests on leaked documents and multiple military sources cited by The Guardian. The 3.5 million figure, the early-2024 timing, the use of Rekognition, the Rolling Stone unit, and the link to Project Nimbus appear consistently across the Guardian investigation and the outlets that reported it the same day. Open questions about the exact origin of every photo and the operational status of the project are also stated in those reports.
Readers can weigh the security purpose described by Israeli sources against the scale of the database and the known accuracy limits of the commercial tool. The documents show a large transfer of personal images into a commercial cloud during an active military campaign. They do not, on the published record, show a finished global targeting system. The difference between those two descriptions is where the current evidence ends and further claims begin.
Original source: Harry Davies and Yuval Abraham, “Revealed: Israel uploaded millions of photos to Amazon’s facial recognition platform to track Palestinians,” The Guardian, 16 November 2026. Read the investigation. Secondary reporting: Jerusalem Post, 16 November 2026. Jerusalem Post summary.
Disclaimer for fact-checkers: The central facts in this article are drawn from The Guardian’s published investigation, which relies on leaked documents and unnamed military sources. Amazon and the IDF have issued limited public statements. Claims that go beyond the documented upload, the stated purpose of facial recognition work, and the known Project Nimbus framework are not supported by the primary reporting cited here.
