Министр Нидерландов заявил, что местная молодёжь может оставаться жить с родителями, пока жильё в первую очередь предоставляется беженцам

В стране, где молодым людям приходится годами ждать, пока они смогут приобрести свое первое жилье, высказывание одного из министров о том, что многие из них «к счастью» могут продолжать жить с родителями, вызвало острую дискуссию. Это заявление прозвучало на фоне появления новых данных ...

Сообщение Planet-Today.com. Перевод заголовка и краткого описания выполнен автоматически.


In a country where young people wait years for a first home, a minister’s remark that many can “fortunately” keep living with their parents has sparked a sharp debate. The comment came as new figures show migration drove most of the extra demand for houses over the past decade. One side sees a practical response to people leaving reception centers. The other sees a system that consistently places newcomers ahead of those born here. The numbers and the arguments on both sides are worth examining closely.

Dutch Minister Says Young Locals Can Stay With Parents While Refugees Get Homes First

Housing Minister Elanor Boekholt-O’Sullivan, of the D66 party, faced strong criticism after an interview with De Telegraaf this week. She was asked why status holders—people who have received residence permits after asylum claims—continue to receive priority for scarce social rental homes. Dutch “starters,” young people looking for their first independent place, face long waiting lists. Her reply was that “we see that a lot of starters can still, or are allowed to, live with their parents.” She added that this was “not ideal,” and that their situation also needed solutions, but the priority for status holders would stay until other options exist.

The minister, born in Cork, Ireland, to an Irish father and Dutch mother, moved to the Netherlands as a small child. She rose through the ranks of the Royal Netherlands Air Force to become a lieutenant general before entering politics earlier this year. In the interview she stated her core principle: anyone who is allowed to live in the Netherlands and wants to should have a roof over their head. Status holders leave asylum reception centers, she said. Leaving them there, or sending them to the streets, hotels, or cruise ships, was not acceptable. Therefore the priority allocation should continue until better solutions are ready.

Critics rejected that framing. Commentator Eva Vlaardingerbroek called the approach “systemic racism.” She wrote that a 25-year-old who arrived from Syria years ago with his family can move ahead in the queue when he decides to live alone, while a young Dutch person of similar age faces waiting lists of ten years or more. “Putting the interests of foreigners above the interests of the native population needs to end,” she said. Coalition partners and opposition figures demanded an apology. None came. Written questions from BBB and criticism from VVD in parliament highlighted the same point: hundreds of thousands of young Dutch people have already spent years on lists, and dismissing their difficulty by pointing to parental homes felt unacceptable to many.

What the Housing Numbers Show

The timing of the remarks coincided with a report from the Economic Institute for Construction (EIB), released on 12 October 2026. The EIB found that migration accounted for about 60 percent of the additional housing demand between 2015 and 2024. Roughly 2.2 million migrants arrived in that period; about 1.4 million remained in 2024. Those who stayed occupied an estimated 435,000 homes. In the same decade the housing stock grew by nearly 700,000 units. The rest of the demand came mainly from smaller household sizes.

The EIB distinguished between types of migration. Labor and knowledge migrants form large inflows, but many leave. About 60 percent of labor migrants depart within ten years; students leave at even higher rates. Asylum-related migrants stay at far higher rates. Only about 5 to 7 percent of status holders leave after five years. As a result, asylum migration builds lasting demand. More than 90 percent of asylum migrants end up in the social rental sector. Labor migrants are more likely to use the private rental or owner-occupied market.

Other figures add context. Reports drawing on Statistics Netherlands data and compiled by platforms such as Nederland In Beeld indicate that households with a first- or second-generation migration background occupy about 44 percent of the country’s roughly 2.2 million social housing units. That share has doubled from 22 percent in 2000 and is projected to reach 51 percent by 2030 if trends continue. Specific groups show even higher concentrations: 92 percent of first-generation Syrians live in social housing, as do around 90 percent of those from Somalia, Afghanistan, and Eritrea. Status holders receive roughly 8 percent of annual social housing allocations overall, but the share is higher in the starter segment.

The overall housing shortage stands at about 410,000 homes, or roughly 4.8 percent of the stock, according to recent consultancy figures. Waiting times in major cities often run many years. Priority rules allow some recent arrivals to bypass ordinary queues. Population growth in recent years has been driven almost entirely by net migration. Strict planning rules, nitrogen regulations, and slow construction have limited new supply.

The Minister’s Position and the Counter-Arguments

Supporters of the current approach argue that status holders start from a different place. They leave organized reception and have no family home to return to. The law requires municipalities to house them. Boekholt-O’Sullivan has said she still wants to end the priority once alternative housing capacity exists; she withdrew an earlier bill aimed at abolishing it and is preparing a replacement. She has acknowledged distressing cases among young Dutch people and has said their problems must also be solved. Municipalities have told her that any extra homes should go to people in the most difficult situations.

Critics counter that the distinction is not neutral in practice. Many young Dutch adults also have no realistic path to independent housing. Parental homes can be too small, parents may be elderly or strained, and adult children can end up without stable options. They note that status holders and their adult children can later claim priority or move within the system, while native starters remain on long lists. They also point to the broader fiscal picture. A 2021 study titled “Borderless Welfare State,” led by Jan van de Beek and others, estimated net costs of immigration to public finances at about €400 billion between 1995 and 2019, averaging roughly €17 billion a year, with a peak of €32 billion in 2016. Subsequent years have added further costs. Economists have disputed parts of the methodology, arguing that non-rivalrous public goods such as defense should not be allocated fully on a per-capita basis. Adjusted estimates are lower, yet the study and official reception budgets still show significant net expenditure, especially for asylum-related groups.

The debate also touches on construction constraints. Nitrogen rules and planning procedures have slowed building for years. Labor migrants, including those in construction, form part of the workforce, yet the net effect on housing has still been a large increase in demand. Asylum migrants, because they stay and concentrate in social housing, add structural pressure that temporary workers do not.

Local Tensions and Wider Patterns

Similar frictions have appeared in Dutch towns for some time. In one case covered on this site, residents of a village protested plans for an asylum center by throwing eggs and hanging pigs’ feet near the site; locals said housing for newcomers appeared while their own children could not find places. Read more on Planet Today. Across Europe, governments face parallel questions about housing, reception capacity, and the balance between obligations to those granted protection and the expectations of existing residents. Britain has recently threatened visa bans on countries that refuse to take back failed asylum claimants. See the related report.

Population and housing data make the scale clearer. Net migration has been the main driver of population growth. Social housing, built and subsidized largely with public resources, has seen its occupancy shift markedly. Projections from the EIB suggest that if net migration can be reduced toward 50,000 people a year—the level recommended by a state commission on demographic development—additional housing demand from migration over the next decade would fall from around 340,000 units under current trends to about 235,000. Demand is expected to stay high until 2030 and then ease if inflows decline.

What Remains Unresolved

The minister’s principle that everyone permitted to live in the country should have a roof is straightforward on its face. The practical question is how that principle operates when supply is short and waiting lists already stretch for years. Status holders arrive from reception centers with legal housing duties attached. Young Dutch adults often have family networks but still face high private rents, purchase prices that lock them out, and queues measured in years. Whether the current priority rules strike a workable balance, or whether they systematically favor one group over another, is the point of contention.

Official statements emphasize that the priority is temporary and that solutions for starters are also needed. Critics argue that the temporary measures have become lasting, that adult children of earlier arrivals can also benefit from preferential access, and that the cumulative effect is visible in both waiting times and the changing composition of social housing. The EIB numbers show migration as the largest single source of extra demand over the past decade, with asylum migration contributing disproportionately to permanent occupancy in the social sector. Fiscal studies, even when their exact totals are debated, document substantial net public costs.

Readers can weigh the minister’s stated principle against the length of ordinary waiting lists, the stay rates of different migrant groups, and the occupancy figures in social housing. The data from the EIB, Statistics Netherlands compilations, and municipal allocation records are public. So are the minister’s words and the replies from parliamentarians and commentators. The gap between those who view the priority as a necessary protection for people leaving reception and those who view it as an unfair delay for people born in the country is unlikely to close soon.

Original source: De Telegraaf interview with Housing Minister Elanor Boekholt-O’Sullivan, 13 October 2026. De Telegraaf. Additional reporting: Remix News, 14 October 2026. Remix News. EIB report “Migratie en de woningmarkt,” 12 October 2026. EIB.

Disclaimer for fact-checkers: This article draws on the cited primary interview, the EIB report, official statistics compilations, and public statements. Figures on social housing occupancy by migration background are derived from CBS-based analyses published by platforms such as Nederland In Beeld and reported by multiple outlets. The €400 billion fiscal estimate comes from the “Borderless Welfare State” study; independent economists have questioned aspects of its methodology regarding non-rivalrous public goods. All claims are presented with their sources so readers can examine the underlying material.

Отправить комментарий

Здесь вы можете оставить свой комментарий

Новые Старые

Форма для связи