Италия расследует дело в отношении группы из Падуи, обвиняемой в создании арбитражного суда, действующего по нормам шариата

Частная организация в Падуе заявляет, что предлагает объективное арбитражное разбирательство по коммерческим сделкам, заключаемым с соблюдением исламских норм в отношении процентов и справедливости. Критики утверждают, что эта же организация пытается создать вторую систему правосудия ...

Сообщение Planet-Today.com. Перевод заголовка и краткого описания выполнен автоматически.


A private body in Padua says it offers fair arbitration for business deals that follow Islamic rules on interest and fairness. Critics say the same body is trying to build a second justice system next to Italian courts. Prosecutors opened a file. No one has been charged. The gap between those two sentences is where the real argument lives.

Italy Probes Padua Group Accused of Sharia Arbitration Court
Source: Video Screenshot

Italian authorities in the northern city of Padua have opened an investigation into a private organization called the Italian Islamic Arbitration Chamber. The group, founded on 3 March 2026, says it helps settle civil and commercial disputes using principles drawn from Sharia. A formal complaint filed by lawyer Francesco Minutillo of the Futuro Nazionale party triggered the probe. At this stage the prosecutor’s office has listed no suspects and named no crime. Justice Minister Carlo Nordio has said he trusts the Padua magistrates to establish the facts. The largest Italian Muslim umbrella group has publicly rejected the initiative. The founder insists the chamber is ordinary private arbitration that must obey Italian law at every step.

The story sits at the edge of two systems that do not always sit easily together: a secular civil code that treats all citizens the same, and a religious legal tradition that some believers want to keep alive in private dealings. Readers can weigh the documents, the statements, and the legal limits for themselves.

How the Padua Chamber Describes Itself

The organization was set up in Padua at Via Armistizio 13. Its founder is Omar Vanin, a 36-year-old lawyer enrolled at the Padua bar and a contract lecturer at the University of Padua in transnational commercial law. Public materials on the group’s site present it as “your path to Islamic justice in Italy.” Its rules refer to the decision-making body as a “Tribunale Sciaraitico” (Sharia tribunal) and state that arbitrators should apply principles common to Islamic nations when deciding according to law. When deciding according to equity, they are to take Islamic principles into account. The chamber lists among its aims the promotion of arbitration as a way to end disputes. Italian outlets reported that the rules claim the resulting awards will carry the same effect as a judgment from an Italian court.

Vanin has told local media that the chamber has handled no actual cases so far. It exists, he says, to give businesses and private parties—including those who prefer Islamic commercial norms—an optional tool. Those norms include the ban on interest (riba), rules of fairness in contracts, and a preference for agreed solutions. He has repeated that Italian law always comes first and that no award can stand if it clashes with Italian public order.

Italian law has long allowed private arbitration for rights that parties can freely dispose of. Commercial and property disputes are classic examples. Family status, divorce, child custody, and core labor rights are not. An arbitral award can later be made enforceable by a state court, but that court checks only formal regularity unless the losing party challenges the substance. Critics argue this formal check is too narrow if community pressure keeps people from appealing.

The Complaint That Started the File

Francesco Minutillo, a lawyer and member of Futuro Nazionale (the party linked to former army general Roberto Vannacci), filed an exposé with the Padua prosecutor’s office. He argued that the chamber’s public presentation and internal rules push Italian law to the side. He pointed to the language of “Islamic justice in Italy,” the title “Tribunale Sciaraitico,” and wording that appears to apply Sharia first and Italian law only where Sharia is silent. Minutillo said the issue is legal, not religious: whether a private body is setting up a parallel system of justice.

On 8 October 2026, Padua prosecutor Angelantonio Racanelli confirmed that his office had opened a modello 45 file. That format allows investigation without naming suspects or a specific crime hypothesis. Racanelli said the office would carry out the checks the law requires. Italian reporting indicated that the Digos police unit is also involved. Nordio publicly expressed full confidence that the magistrates would clarify every point.

Parliamentary questions followed from Lega, Fratelli d’Italia, and Italia Viva. The case moved from a local complaint to national debate within days.

What Italian Muslim Organizations Said

The Union of Islamic Communities of Italy (UCOII), the country’s largest Muslim umbrella body, issued a clear public distancing. It called the chamber a “so-called” initiative launched by people unknown to Italian Islamic communities and without any mandate from them. No association, center, or mosque linked to UCOII promoted, supported, or even consulted on it. UCOII stated that justice in Italy is administered by the courts of the Republic in line with the Constitution and state laws. That system, it said, fully protects the rights of citizens and residents, including Muslims, and needs no parallel structures. On the religious side, UCOII recalled that Islamic tradition requires believers to respect the laws of the country where they live, and that turning to state justice is consistent with the faith.

Other voices inside Italian Islam were also cautious. Yahya Sergio Yahe Pallavicini, vice-president of COREIS, described the project as risky. He noted that the promoters’ authority and competence remain unclear, and that such bodies can help form closed communities that function like ghettos. He distinguished internal religious norms (which exist for Catholics and Jews as well) from any structure that presents itself as an alternative to the state order.

These statements matter because they come from groups that have long negotiated with the Italian state over recognition and places of worship. They show that the rejection is not limited to political opponents of immigration.

The Founder’s Defense in His Own Words

Vanin has responded in interviews and notes to local outlets such as Padova Oggi and Il Mattino di Padova. He has said the chamber “is not a court” and “does not administer a form of alternative justice, and it could not be otherwise.” He described arbitration as a tool that has always existed inside the Italian legal system for commercial and property disputes. Parties who want to apply Islamic commercial principles—such as no interest, fairness, and consensual outcomes—may do so, he argued, provided every step stays inside Italian law.

He expressed regret that institutional statements had amplified a narrative of division. The work of the chamber, he said, aims at the opposite: dialogue, mediation, and resolution in full compliance with Italian rules. Vanin has also noted that family matters cannot be handled by arbitration under Italian law, a point confirmed by the president of the Padua lawyers’ order.

Whether the actual written regulations match this description is one of the questions the prosecutor’s checks will examine. Italian reporting has quoted passages that place Sharia principles in a primary position and Italian law in a residual one. Vanin maintains that any award that violated public order (for example, by discriminating against a woman simply because of her sex) would be void.

Legal Limits and Practical Risks

Italian arbitration law is clear on paper. Parties may choose arbitrators and even agree on the rules those arbitrators will apply, as long as the subject matter is arbitrable and the outcome does not offend public order or mandatory rules. Enforcement still runs through state courts. A party who loses can challenge the award on limited grounds. If no one challenges it, the formal check is narrow.

Critics, including Minutillo and several parliamentarians, focus on two practical points. First, the public branding and internal language can create the impression of a second court. Second, community pressure may stop the losing party from going to a state judge. One reported clause (Article 30 in the chamber’s rules) allows the body, under certain conditions, to notify local Islamic associations about the outcome. Opponents say this could function as social enforcement outside the legal system. Supporters say it is merely information sharing among private parties.

Funding and governance have also drawn attention. Quotidiano Nazionale reported on 9–10 October 2026 that the names of other founders are redacted in public documents, costs are unclear, and questions remain about who finances the project. The paper traced commercial links through consulting firms that work with Gulf markets and noted the size of the global Islamic finance sector (nearly $6 trillion in 2024 according to LSEG data). No public evidence has established illegal funding; the opacity itself is the issue under discussion.

Comparisons with the United Kingdom are common in the Italian debate. Unofficial Sharia councils there have handled family disputes for years. UK reviews found problems with pressure on women, unequal treatment, and weak transparency. Italy’s stronger public-order limits and the early stage of the Padua project make a direct copy unlikely, but the precedent is part of the public conversation.

Context from Other Italian Cases

The Padua probe arrives against a background of repeated clashes between certain imported norms and Italian criminal and family law. In July 2026 Italy’s Court of Cassation confirmed life sentences for the parents and two cousins of Saman Abbas, the 18-year-old strangled in 2021 after she refused an arranged marriage. Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni stated that Italy has no room for cultural or religious justifications that deny a woman’s freedom and life. Related cases in the same region have involved forced marriage pressure and long-term family captivity. These judgments rest on ordinary Italian criminal law; they do not depend on any religious arbitration body. They do illustrate why many Italians treat any new structure that invokes religious rules for dispute resolution with caution.

At the same time, private arbitration remains a normal commercial tool used by companies of every background. The legal question is whether the Padua chamber stays inside those ordinary limits or steps outside them through its rules, branding, or methods of enforcement.

What Remains Open

As of 10 October 2026 the prosecutor’s file is open and the checks continue. No charges have been filed. Vanin has said he is ready to defend the chamber’s reputation through the proper legal channels. UCOII and other Muslim bodies have told their communities not to treat the chamber as legitimate. Parliamentarians from several parties have asked ministers for clarifications. The outcome will depend on a close reading of the statutes, the regulations, any actual awards (none yet reported), and whether the practice matches the founder’s public assurances.

Private parties in Italy already choose foreign law or religious principles in many commercial contracts, provided the result can be reconciled with Italian public order. The Padua case tests how far that choice can be packaged, branded, and presented as “Islamic justice” before it collides with the principle that only state courts administer justice for everyone. The documents, the statements, and the prosecutor’s eventual findings will decide which description fits.

Related reading on this site: Life Sentences Confirmed: Pakistani Family Jailed for Honor Killing of Teen Daughter Saman Abbas in Italy and Pakistani Woman Escapes Year-Long Family Captivity in Italy.

Original source: Breitbart, 9 October 2026 – Italy Opens Probe Into Organization Allegedly Acting as Autonomous ‘Sharia Court’ in Padua. Primary Italian reporting appears in ANSA (8 October 2026), Il Giornale, Corriere del Veneto, and Rai News.

Disclaimer for fact-checkers: The existence of the prosecutorial file, the dates, the founder’s identity, the UCOII statement, and the minister’s comment are confirmed across multiple Italian public and private outlets. Breitbart is a secondary aggregator of those reports. Readers should consult the Italian primary sources for full context and any later updates. No claim of criminal guilt has been made by authorities at the time of writing.

Отправить комментарий

Здесь вы можете оставить свой комментарий

Новые Старые

Форма для связи